Having now watched both the pilot mini-series and season 1 of the ‘new’ Battlestar Galactica, I’m quite shocked at how different it is. The campness has been pretty much been completely replaced with a sense of gritty realism (apart from the goings-on inside Baltar’s head).
Turning Apollo and Starbuck into mere callsigns instead of actual names was a good move, as was the inspired casting of the original Apollo as Tom Zarak. I’ve got mixed feelings about Starbuck’s gender-switching – it definately gives the pairing a renewed dynamic, but it also brought along some emotional baggage, that wouldn’t have been there if Starbuck remained male.
On the other hand I’m not a fan of the new theme tune, and I also think the original 1970′s model-based FX outshine the modern CGI counterparts more often than not. And what’s with the bullets instead of lasers?
One other thing that annoys me (along with a lot of other shows), is the fact that the opening credits display the actor’s names without either their photo, or even their character name, leaving me clueless as to who plays who!
It’s still an enjoyable show (when you aren’t comparing it to the original), and I’ll definately be picking up season 2 when it gets released here in the UK.

Feeds